Why Does fnmatch Behave Differently on Windows and Linux? Do OS Differences Affect Matching Results?

M66 2025-06-27

In programming, the fnmatch() function is commonly used to match filenames based on patterns. In PHP, fnmatch() is primarily used for pattern matching within the file system, such as with wildcard expressions. However, many developers have noticed that fnmatch() behaves differently across platforms, especially between Windows and Linux environments. So why does fnmatch() behave differently on these two operating systems? Do OS-level differences really affect how filenames are matched?

1. Basic Functionality of fnmatch()

First, let’s understand the basic usage of the fnmatch() function. It is used to compare a given string against a pattern. The syntax is as follows:

fnmatch(string $pattern, string $filename, int $flags = 0): bool

$pattern: The pattern to match against, typically containing wildcards like * or ?.
$filename: The filename to be tested.
$flags: Optional flags that modify the matching behavior.

For example:

fnmatch('*.txt', 'document.txt');  // Returns true because the match is successful
fnmatch('test?.php', 'test1.php'); // Returns true because the match is successful

2. Differences in fnmatch() Across Operating Systems

2.1 Behavior in Windows

On Windows, fnmatch() performs case-insensitive filename matching. This is due to the nature of Windows file systems like NTFS and FAT32, which are case-insensitive by default. As a result, fnmatch() ignores letter case differences during matching.

For instance, on Windows, if the filename is test.TXT, then fnmatch('*.txt', 'test.TXT') will return true because case is not considered during the match.

2.2 Behavior in Linux

On the other hand, Linux file systems such as ext4 are case-sensitive. This means that fnmatch() in Linux will strictly enforce case matching. It does not ignore case differences automatically.

For example, on Linux, fnmatch('*.txt', 'test.TXT') will return false, since the extension in test.TXT does not match the lowercase *.txt pattern.

3. Root Causes of OS-Level Differences

The different behavior of fnmatch() across platforms stems from fundamental differences in the design of Windows and Linux file systems.

Windows: File systems like NTFS or FAT32 do not differentiate between uppercase and lowercase by default. For instance, Test.TXT and test.txt are treated as the same file.
Linux: File systems like ext4 are case-sensitive by default. On Linux, Test.TXT and test.txt are entirely different files, and case sensitivity is strictly enforced during matching.

Since fnmatch() reflects the file system behavior, it results in different matching outcomes on Windows and Linux.

4. How to Ensure Cross-Platform Consistency

To avoid inconsistent behavior of fnmatch() across different platforms, developers can apply some strategies to standardize the results.

Normalize filename case: Convert both the pattern and filename to lowercase or uppercase before matching to ensure consistent behavior regardless of the operating system. For example, use strtolower() or strtoupper() as shown below:
```
$pattern = strtolower('*.txt');
$filename = strtolower('Test.TXT');
fnmatch($pattern, $filename); // Ensures consistent case
```
Use the flags parameter: The third parameter in fnmatch() allows for modifying behavior. For instance, using the FNM_CASEFOLD flag forces case-insensitive matching:
```
fnmatch('*.txt', 'Test.TXT', FNM_CASEFOLD);  // Case-insensitive on both Windows and Linux
```

5. Conclusion

fnmatch() behaves differently on Windows and Linux due to the inherent differences in their file systems. Windows file systems are typically case-insensitive, while Linux file systems tend to be case-sensitive. These differences result in varying behaviors when using fnmatch(), especially in terms of case sensitivity. By properly using the function’s flags and normalizing filename cases, developers can achieve consistent cross-platform behavior and minimize the impact of OS-level differences on matching results.

fnmatch